[Korea Beyond Korea] 'Funding drought jeopardizes interest in ancient Korea studies in US'
简介While a growing number of college students abroad want to learn about Korea thanks to the country’s ...
While a growing number of college students abroad want to learn about Korea thanks to the country’s popular culture, most universities around the world still lack faculty, courses and textbooks for key areas of Korean studies such as pre-modern Korean history.
Virtually all the Korean history professors that teach at universities such as Harvard and UCLA specialize in Joseon Dynasty (1392-1910) or post-Joseon Korea. There are no faculty specializing in ancient or medieval Korean history, which means those interested in Korea before the 15th century have to learn from Chinese or Japanese history professors or textbooks.
“A number of scholars have left the field, and very few are remaining. Only two or three scholars who deal with prehistoric archaeology of Korea have faculty positions,” said Mark Byington, who runs the nonprofit, Cambridge Institute for the Study of Korea, to provide a space for academic research on Korea.
The primary reason, according to the US-based scholar, is the prolonged and persistent funding drought.
“US universities are generally not interested in taking funding for study of early Korean history or archaeology. You have to have a faculty member who is interested in the field,” Byington said in a recent interview.
The Korean government, in the past, had run programs to promote the academic study of early Korean history and archaeology overseas, like the “Early Korea Project” that began in 2006 at Harvard University. Byington led the project as its director.
But the entire project was terminated in 2018 after funding from Korean state-funded institutions was cut off due to political problems in Korea.
“The Early Korea Project was extremely lucky because there was a senior Korean literature professor (now retired David McCann) at Harvard who thought early Korean history and archaeology were important,” Byington said.
Ever since the project lost funding, the state of studies of early Korea in the US has been bad, and is getting worse each year.
His CISK “provides scholars interested in Korea with something similar to what the Early Korea Project provided, as a way to share their scholarship, but getting it funded has been a problem,” he said.
However, the resumption of a grant project in South Korea, matching the scope and scale of the Early Korea Project, seems improbable at present. Officials in Seoul express concerns about the potential recurrence of the political noise that disrupted the Harvard project.
The Early Korea Project, consisting of lectures, workshops and publications on the academic study of early Korean history and archaeology, focused on periods prior to the 10th century, and received multi-year support from Korean state-funded institutions such as the Academy of Korean Studies, Korea Foundation and Northeast Asian History Foundation (NAHF).
Then, Lee Deok-il, who leads the Hangaram History and Culture Institute in Seoul, raised an issue about a book titled, “The Han Commanderies in Early Korean History,” which Byington wrote as part of the project.
One of the four commanderies, known as Lelang, was located in what is now Pyongyang, according to the book and mainstream Korean historians. Lee, however, claims that this was colonial Japan’s view of history, and that the Lelang Commandery was in fact outside of the Korean Peninsula. Lee also took issue with historical maps that the NAHF was working on, saying that some of them look just like China’s ancient maps.
The issues raised by Lee got on the agenda of a parliamentary special committee with the stated purpose of coming up with “countermeasures for distortions in Northeast Asian history."
Lawmakers on the committee publicly chastised the NAHF over the maps as supporting a Chinese perspective of early East Asian history. In the whirlwind of disputes, funding for both projects – the maps and the Early Korea Project – was cut off.
“Korean mainstream scholars did their best to explain to the special committee (the absurdity of Lee’s attacks), but the committee had already made up their minds,” Byington said, adding that even Korean media such as JoongAng Ilbo were not interested in interviewing him at the time.
Western scholars who are familiar with Korean history are generally aware of the problems of “pseudohistory” in Korea, he said, referring to the likes of Lee.
The Hangaram Institute states on its official website that its goal is to counter and debunk the “Sino-centric and Japanese colonialist perspectives” prevalent among mainstream historians. These views, it asserts, result in distortions of Korean history that make Korea’s historical timeline shorter and territorial space smaller.
“There are some good academic studies in English on this pseudohistory, its origins and development, and the interests of those who push fringe views,” Byington said.
The difficulty of access to archaeological sites now in North Korea limits scholarship on the early states of that region, and this is true also of sites in China, but to a lesser degree, according to him.
“Unfortunately, when there is a significant lack of information, this provides an invitation to pseudohistorians to speculate on what might be missing, which in turn leads to wild and unsubstantiated claims,” he said.
“I think it would be useful for western scholars to be aware of the effects of pseudohistory within Korea, including academia, to understand better why certain issues are viewed as important or sensitive to many people in Korea today.”
“Korean Studies Beyond Korea” explores the current landscape of Korean studies through interviews, in-depth analyses and on-the-ground stories told from diverse world areas. Funded by the Korea Press Foundation, this series will delve into the challenges and opportunities facing the field as Korea's rise as a cultural powerhouse has drawn interest from scholars, researchers and leaders from around the globe. – Ed.
The wealth gap between younger and older adults has widened over the last few years, largely dependi ...
Prime Minister Han Duck-soo will meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the open ...
The Gangwon Forestry Exhibition 2023 kicked off on Friday around Gangwon Province's Seoraksan N ...
Biz outlook stays flat for October amid slowing economy
PM to meet with Xi on sidelines of Asian Games in Hangzhou
Seoul shares close lower amid woes over Fed's drawn
Korea’s parental leave benefits lag behind OECD average
Seoul streets transform to open stage for Seoul Street Arts Festival
Russian FM to visit Pyongyang next month as follow
- [New in Korean] Year 2020 revisited under shadow of disconnection
- S. Korea, US conduct underwater search operation for downed jet, Korean War remains
- [Korea Beyond Korea] 'Funding drought jeopardizes interest in ancient Korea studies in US'
- 2m Koreans opt out of life
- BTS' Jungkook to drop new single '3D'
- [Book Review] 'Lee Kun
- Yoon pushes for Xi’s visit to firm up ties with China
- Apple to launch iPhone15 series in S. Korea on Oct. 13
- Surveillance cameras to be a must in hospital operating rooms
- Russian top diplomat to visit NK, accuses US of fueling tensions on Korean Peninsula
- "KTX 꼭 타보고 싶다" 했던 김정은 "만족한 합의"…뭐길래
- Incheon Airport passenger traffic to recover during Chuseok holiday
- 합의문도 없는 희한한 북·러 정상회담…결국 비즈니스 관계였나
- 한동훈, 체포안 설명 8분 넘기자…“짧게 합시다” “왜 이리 시끄럽냐”
- [이번 주 리뷰]美 Fed 기준금리 동결…이재명 체포동의안 가결(18~23일)
- FSS issues advisories to fisheries cooperatives federation for W50b investment loss
- 야당 29명 반란, 이재명 방탄 뚫렸다
- ‘Do you know Dr. Hong?’ Moms say they wish they didn’t
- Young swimmer enjoys self
- Nam June Paik Art Center to be led by new director Park Nam
- [사진] 영장심사 마친 이재명, 묵묵부답
- “러시아 공군기, 평양 도착…북러 간 접촉 활발”
- Yoon plans state visits to UK, Netherlands later this year
- Chief justice seat at top court left vacant amid Assembly chaos
- 北주민 굶어 죽어도…김여정 디오르, 최선희는 구찌 '명품 사랑'
- [Herald Review] ‘Carmen’ redefines iconic femme fatale as stalking victim
- Hospital visits during Chuseok cost up to 50% more
- Seoul streets transform to open stage for Seoul Street Arts Festival
- Immersive, digital art shows to enjoy during extended holiday
- S. Korea’s consumer sentiment turns sour in September: BOK index